Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is rightfully bearing the brunt of the blame amid the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO)’s announcement that the U.S. lost its measles elimination status for the first time in nearly 27 years. Much of the damage was self-inflicted by the administration.
Kayla Hancock, Director of Protect Our Care’s Public Health Project: “Unsurprisingly, RFK Jr — the most infamous anti-vaxxer on Earth, RFK Jr — takes no responsibility for non-stop measles transmission on his watch that’s left 10 dead this year. Absurdly, Kennedy claims he’s now the one to ‘rebuild public trust.’ For over 20 years, RFK Jr. laid the groundwork for this public health tragedy by founding the nation’s top anti-vax propaganda group. As health secretary, he abused his power to amplify MMR disinformation on the national stage, which sped up the decline in vaccination rates and the spread of measles. Anti-vaxxer-in-chief Donald Trump has only pushed Sec. Kennedy to do more damage to public trust in vaccines, like bribing doctors to report vaccine injuries and go fishing for any data they can use to scare parents. Measles shouldn’t be back, but it is with a vengeance thanks to this administration. Every day Kennedy digs in at HHS is a day our children are left more vulnerable to preventable diseases that kill.”
WHAT LAWMAKERS ARE SAYING:
- Senator Patty Murray (D-WA): “Trump and RFK Jr. turned back the clock and brought a deadly, preventable disease roaring back. This is outrageous. Measles cases are at record highs, ten people have died from measles this year, including infants. Instead of doing everything in his power to stop this, RFK Jr. has accused state health officials of exaggerating the outbreak, suggested the deaths may have been ‘fabricated,’ and changed how the CDC counts measles deaths—Americans deserve real leadership, not a coverup. Trump has given RFK Jr. free rein to spread conspiracy theories and this is the result. Vaccines are safe and effective—full stop. If we had an HHS Secretary willing to say that plainly, we would not be watching children die of a disease this country beat a generation ago.”
- Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR), expected new chair the Senate Finance Committee: “Trump, Vance and Republicans empowered Robert Kennedy and his deputies to run America’s public health into the ground, and they have blood on their hands.”
- Sen. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.), a member of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee: “The first thing I think about is the kids and the individuals whose lives are in jeopardy right now. Just like we’ve called for accountability before, we need to do that again. RFK needs to come before our committee.”
- Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), expected new chair of the Senate HELP Committee: “Secretary Kennedy promised to ‘Make America Healthy Again. Instead, after 26 years, the United States has officially lost its status as a country that stopped the spread of measles. Shameful.”
- Gov. Andy Beshear (D-KY): “This dangerous setback was 100% avoidable and is the result of one person: RFK Jr. Remove him now.”
- Senator Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD): “Public health officials worked tirelessly for decades to achieve measles elimination status in the United States—and in less than two years at the helm, RFK Jr. rolled back over a quarter century of progress. An utter disgrace. Our nation was once the envy around the world, the crown jewel of medical advancement, research, and discovery. Now our health is held hostage by the lies of a conspiracy theorist. Countless American lives will continue to be lost because of RFK Jr.’s disastrous tenure.”
- Congresswoman Kim Schrier, M.D. (WA-08): “The U.S. just lost its measles elimination status. Measles is on the rise because of RFK Jr.’s misinformation campaign, which has scared parents and botched the measles outbreak response. Now, the nation that has always led the world in medicine is reversing course. As a pediatrician, I will continue to lay every death from a vaccine-preventable disease at RFK Jr.’s feet. RFK Jr. must resign now or be prepared to face oversight and accountability from Congressional Democrats. Children’s lives are on the line.”
- Rep Kelly Morrison (D-MN-3): “Kennedy has really profited off of his campaign of misinformation for years before the president appointed him to lead our biggest public health organizations. And since then, he has done a lot to worsen the situation. … I believe that he would also agree that Kennedy has to go. So there may be a bipartisan effort to move on, put this chapter behind us and begin rebuilding American public health.”
- Senator-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC): “RFK Jr. has been peddling an anti-vaccine conspiracy theories for decades, and he is directly responsible for the rise of vaccine hesitancy and vaccine refusal that I’ve seen over my 20-year career as a practicing pediatrician. And therefore, he’s also directly responsible for the measles outbreaks that we’ve experienced across this country, including in Spartanburg County, South Carolina, where we had almost 1,000 documented cases of the measles. So, the time for accountability is here. But, number one, he has no business leading HHS. He needs to be removed from that position. We need to put someone who understands evidence-based medicine, basic scientific principles in charge of our nation’s Department of Health and Human Services. And I cannot wait to get started at my new job on January 3, because we have no time to waste here.”
- Senate HELP Committee chair Bill Cassidy (R-LA): “If I were president, I would choose someone else because there needs to be accountability for higher healthcare costs, more measles deaths, losing elimination status, and no progress on processed foods.”
- Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI): “We’ve created the space for a few grifters to come in and in effect lie to the public. To create a level of distrust in science and in public health that has had disastrous consequences.”
WHAT EXPERTS ARE SAYING:
- Georges C. Benjamin, MD, head of the American Public Health Association: “They’ve botched this response. This one stinks at the top. Kennedy, you got to go.”
- National Nurses United, the largest nurses’ union in the U.S.: “The return of measles to the United States is an entirely preventable public health failure that endangers our most vulnerable patients,” said Jamie Brown, RN and NNU president. “It is unconscionable but not surprising that the Trump administration’s top national health official is promoting lies about vaccines on top of the harmful cuts and policies he has advanced. It is past time to impeach Secretary Kennedy, and the public cannot wait a day longer.”
- Dr. Jonathan Reiner, cardiologist and CNN medical analyst: “RFK Jr. is the primary culprit in spreading doubt about this vaccine.”
IN THE NEWS:
- Reuters, 11.17: How Kennedy let measles run wild in America: Historically, US government leaders urgently mobilized disease experts to halt such outbreaks and publicly warned families to vaccinate children. Infections hit dozens or hundreds of people, at most, and outbreaks were often contained within weeks. Now, under US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr – the nation’s leading anti-vaccine activist – some top officials in Utah and elsewhere have stopped promoting immunization and done little to check outbreaks. … With US President Donald Trump’s support, Kennedy tells Americans to fear vaccines, contradicting decades of evidence showing their safety and effectiveness, and promotes policies reducing childhood immunization. He argues children build stronger immunity through direct exposure – by getting sick.”
- The Atlantic, 11.14: RFK Jr. Failed America on Measles: As one CDC official, whose name I’m withholding to protect them from professional repercussions, recently told me, “The response has lacked a clear strategy and support from the top.” […] But under Kennedy, the CDC’s response has also at times appeared constrained. The Washington Post reported that an alert that CDC scientists wanted to send regarding the risks of measles during pregnancy was not approved for unclear reasons. […] Kennedy has also kept mum on the many false statements about measles and vaccination from his allies and supporters. The anti-vaccine nonprofit Kennedy founded, Children’s Health Defense, published an article in September saying that “parents don’t need to be afraid of the measles” and asserting incorrectly that the virus can make children stronger. A week later, after four people had died in Pennsylvania, Kennedy told attendees at a Children’s Health Defense conference, “You have a strong and steadfast friend at the White House.” None of this reflects well on the health secretary, but he has shown no sign that he’ll change course.
- New York TImes, U.S. Loses Its Measles Elimination Status, a Historic Setback for American Health: But experts said under the leadership of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., federal health officials did too little to control outbreaks early on. And they criticized Mr. Kennedy himself for at times directly undermining efforts to improve vaccination rates, by promoting unproven treatments for measles and undermining confidence in childhood vaccines. “I don’t think it’s an accident that this is happening under the current administration,” said Dr. William Moss, an epidemiologist at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health who has studied measles for more than 25 years.
###
